Seven D&O Run-Off Mistakes That Leave Directors Exposed After a Sale
A D&O tail bought in the last week before closing usually ends too early, costs more than it should and keeps every flaw of the old policy. Here are seven D&O run-off cover mistakes to fix before you sign.
What happens to your D&O policy the day the deal closes
If your company is being sold, merged or wound down, your directors and officers policy will probably stop protecting your board for anything they do after closing. Most D&O wordings contain a change in control clause. When an acquirer takes majority ownership or control of the board, or the company merges into another entity, the policy goes into run-off automatically. It still responds to claims about wrongful acts before the transaction date. It covers nothing after it. Some older or local wordings simply end at the next expiry unless you extend them.
That's what D&O run-off cover is for. It extends the period in which former directors can report claims about pre-closing decisions, typically for one to six years, and you pay for it once, up front. The claims it exists for arrive late: a buyer alleging the sale process was misrepresented, minority shareholders challenging the price, a regulator looking back at pre-sale disclosures, a liquidator reviewing the last two years of trading.
These decisions are mostly permanent. Once the tail is bound and the seller has gone, the terms are very hard to reopen. The seven mistakes below most often leave former directors exposed, and each comes with the term to negotiate instead.
Mistake 1: Picking a tail length that runs out before claims can
Boards often accept whatever the broker quotes first, commonly one or three years, without checking it against the limitation periods that apply to them. Directors can be sued for years after a sale. In many legal systems the clock starts when the claimant discovers the problem, not when the decision was made, so real exposure can outlast the headline period.
| Jurisdiction (examples) | Commonly cited period for claims against directors | Run-off implication |
|---|---|---|
| UK, Australia, Singapore | Generally around six years for many contract and tort claims; longer for deeds and some latent damage claims | Six years is the usual baseline |
| Germany | Around five years for many director liability claims; longer for listed companies | Listed groups may need more than six years, or a top-up |
| United States | Varies by state and claim; federal securities fraud claims have a short discovery period plus a longer outer limit of several years | Six years is standard in public M&A |
| India | A few years for general civil claims; regulatory proceedings can reach further back | Shorter statute, but regulatory exposure argues for a longer tail |
| UAE and wider Gulf region | Often several years for director liability under companies law | Five to six years is common |
Treat the table as orientation only. Start dates, tolling rules and exceptions differ by country and claim type.
Negotiate instead: a tail matching the longest limitation period that realistically applies in every country where the company had directors, investors or regulators. For most cross-border deals that means six years. Have local counsel confirm the periods.
Mistake 2: Pricing run-off after the change in control has triggered
Run-off costs most when you buy it under time pressure. Once control has changed, the insurer knows the seller has to buy, the deal is public, and some policies allow only a short window, often weeks, to take up the extended reporting option. Underwriters will also ask about the transaction, and any dispute that has surfaced will show up in the price or in a new exclusion.
| Run-off period | Typical 2026 one-off premium (as % of expiring annual premium) |
|---|---|
| 1 year | 75%–125% |
| 3 years | 125%–200% |
| 6 years | 150%–300% |
These are indicative market ranges. They vary by contract, claims history, sector and region, so confirm them with your broker and insurers. Hypothetically, a 60-person software company with a $5 million limit and a $45,000 annual premium might see a six-year quote of roughly $70,000 to $135,000. If a dispute is already open when the tail goes to market, expect a meaningfully higher figure, or a refusal.
Negotiate instead: a pre-agreed run-off option written into the policy at the last renewal before a sale process, fixing the length and the percentage of premium in advance. If that's too late, get firm quotes at term-sheet stage and bind on or before closing, not after.
Mistake 3: Letting the expiring policy's exclusions carry over into the tail
A run-off extends the policy you already have, so every weakness in it comes along. Three exclusions cause most post-sale disputes.
- Insured versus insured. After closing, the buyer controls the company. If the company then sues its former directors, a broad insured-versus-insured exclusion may block cover. You need a carve-out for claims brought by or on behalf of the company after a change in control.
- Major shareholder exclusions. Some wordings exclude claims by holders above a set threshold, often somewhere between 10% and 25%. The acquirer now holds close to 100%.
- Specific matter and prior-knowledge exclusions. These are often added when the deal is disclosed to underwriters. Push to narrow them to named matters instead of accepting vague wording such as "any claim arising from the transaction."
Also check the continuity or prior-and-pending litigation date. If the program changed insurers recently, that date may be later than you'd assume.
Negotiate instead: a wording review before the run-off is bound, with specific buyer-claim carve-outs and the original continuity date kept. A clean six-year tail on a flawed wording is still a flawed six years.
Mistake 4: Leaving buyer-versus-seller responsibility vague in the purchase agreement
Who arranges and pays for D&O tail coverage after acquisition is a commercial point. It belongs in the sale agreement, not in an email chain the week before closing. Practice varies. In US public company mergers, buyers commonly agree to keep directors insured for six years and cap the cost at a multiple of the current annual premium. In private deals across the UK, Europe and Asia-Pacific, the seller often buys the run-off and the cost is reflected in the price. A buyer with its own global program sometimes offers to cover the old directors under that program instead, which hands control of the cover to the buyer.
If the agreement is silent, the usual result is a hurried argument about cost, followed by the cheapest tail anyone will sign off.
Negotiate instead: a covenant that specifies:
- who buys the run-off and who pays, including any premium cap
- the minimum limit, the length and the minimum insurer financial strength rating
- wording at least as broad as the expiring policy
- a ban on the buyer cancelling, amending or eroding the policy
- continued indemnification of former directors through the company's articles or bylaws for the same period
Use M&A counsel and a broker together. This is a negotiation about the contract and the insurance at once.
Mistake 5: Assuming the run-off limit refreshes each year
A six-year run-off does not give you six years' worth of limits. Almost every tail carries a single aggregate limit for the whole period. If a securities claim uses $3 million of a $5 million limit in year two, every later claim through year six shares the remaining $2 million, and defense costs usually erode the limit too.
It gets worse when the limit is shared with entity cover. Under a standard Side A/B/C policy, the company's own securities defense (Side C) can use up the money the individuals were relying on. After a sale the company belongs to the buyer, who has no particular reason to preserve the limit for your former directors.
Negotiate instead: one or both of the following.
- A dedicated Side A run-off, or difference-in-conditions cover, that only individuals can access. For many mid-size companies it costs a fraction of the main tail and is the cheapest way to protect directors personally.
- A higher run-off limit than the expiring program, if the transaction itself raises the risk, for example a contested take-private or a sale at a valuation minority holders dispute.
For boards of companies with outside investors, a separate Side A layer is usually worth paying for. It's the one part of the program a buyer or liquidator can't easily reach.
Mistake 6: Forgetting sold subsidiaries, local policies and outside directorships
Many M&A D&O insurance problems happen away from the parent company. When a group sells a subsidiary rather than the whole business, that subsidiary usually stops being an insured entity on the date of disposal. Its directors keep cover for earlier acts only to the extent the parent's wording allows. Some wordings are generous, some are silent and some are unclear.
Multinational programs add another layer. Several countries expect or require locally admitted policies, including Brazil and China and a number of others across Latin America, Asia and Africa. Those local policies have their own change in control terms and run-off options. Premium taxes and admitted-market rules differ by country, and a master policy run-off won't automatically extend the local ones.
Then there are outside directorships, such as executives sitting on joint venture or portfolio company boards. Those extensions often end with the main policy.
Negotiate instead: a schedule, built before signing, of every entity, local policy and outside board seat, with the run-off position of each. Get written confirmation from the lead insurer of how the master tail and each local tail respond, and buy local run-offs where the master policy can't legally pay a claim.
Mistake 7: Running a wind-down the same way as a sale
A solvent wind-down or an insolvency carries more personal risk for directors than a sale, and the run-off has to reflect that. Once a company is dissolved, it can't indemnify anyone, so Side A becomes the directors' only protection. In many jurisdictions, liquidators, administrators and creditor representatives can pursue directors over the final months of trading, preferential payments or breaches of duty. Those claims often come years after the company has closed.
Check three things. First, any insolvency or bankruptcy exclusion: some local wordings still exclude claims connected to the company's insolvency. Second, whether a claim brought by a liquidator falls within the insured-versus-insured carve-out. Third, whether the run-off premium has been paid in full and the policy is non-cancellable. An unpaid premium in an insolvent estate can let the insurer cancel.
Negotiate instead: run-off bound and paid before the formal wind-down starts, with a six-year term, non-cancellable status, a Side A layer and no insolvency exclusion. Record the purchase in a board resolution.
Whatever the transaction type, do this week: ask your broker for the current policy's change in control clause, the run-off option terms and a six-year quote with a separate Side A option. Send them to deal counsel before the next draft of the sale agreement. If any term can't be confirmed in writing before signing, treat it as unresolved and keep it in the negotiation.
Frequently asked questions
How long should D&O run-off cover last after a sale?
For most cross-border transactions, six years is the practical baseline because it matches or exceeds many common limitation periods. Some jurisdictions and listed-company situations justify longer cover or a top-up. Confirm the periods that apply to your directors with local counsel before choosing a length.
What does a six-year D&O run-off cost?
As a typical 2026 market range, a six-year run-off often costs a one-off 150% to 300% of the expiring annual premium. Pricing depends on claims history, sector, deal risk and region, and it varies by contract. Get firm quotes from your broker early, ideally before the change in control triggers.
Does the buyer or the seller pay for D&O tail coverage after acquisition?
It depends on the deal. In public mergers the buyer often agrees to maintain the cover up to a premium cap. In private deals the seller often buys it and the cost is reflected in the price. Either way, responsibility, limit, length and a ban on cancellation should be written into the sale agreement.
What does a change in control clause in a D&O policy actually do?
It usually converts the policy into run-off automatically when an acquirer takes control or the company merges. Cover continues for wrongful acts before the transaction date and stops for later acts. Some wordings also set a short window to buy an extended reporting period, so read the clause before the deal is announced.
Can our directors just be added to the buyer's D&O program instead?
Sometimes, but the buyer's insurer may exclude prior acts. The buyer also controls the limit and the renewals, and could reduce the cover later. A separate run-off on your existing policy, ideally with a dedicated Side A layer, gives former directors more certainty.
Is warranty and indemnity or representations and warranties insurance a substitute for D&O run-off?
No. W&I or R&W insurance protects the buyer against losses from breaches of the sale agreement's warranties, while D&O run-off protects individual directors against claims about their conduct. Most deals need both, and the two policies should be reviewed together so gaps and overlaps are handled deliberately.
Written by the Breach Risk Direct editorial team. Prices, features and rules change often - confirm details with the vendor or a licensed professional before you decide.